Naked Whiz reviews

yukoff · Posted: May 15 2011 Post subject: Naked Whiz reviews

As I was browsing through their reviews, I noticed a lot of them were written in 2005 or earlier. Just curious to see if you folks think these old reviews still reflect the product as they are today.
_________________
Greg

NAVET · Posted: May 30 2011 Post subject:

I can't say ALL of their reviews as I haven't tried all of their Charcoal but I have tried a few of them and they were good.

At the least you could narrow down the field of what you'd like to try and not try.
_________________
AD1 (AW) Ret

Competitive BBQ; The only sport where a fat, bald man can be looked upon as a hero.

Johnpv · Joined: 30 May 2011 Posts: 22 Location: NJ

Johnds · Newbie Joined: 03 May 2011 Posts: 43

[quote="yukoff"]As I was browsing through their reviews, I noticed a lot of them were written in 2005 or earlier. Just curious to see if you folks think these old reviews still reflect the product as they are today.[/quote]

The site is not a full time business obviously, and they don't invest a great deal of effort on a day to day basis.

I think the site is a great resource, and you can always go to the reader's reviews for each brand to get more info.

John

necron 99 · Posted: Jun 09 2011 Post subject:

Some of the lump charcoal brands listed on TNW's site are no longer offered for sale (Picnic brand lump, BBQ-Pro brand lump, and New Braunfels Mesquite brand lump are several examples). It would be nice if such charcoal reviews were placed in an archive section with a seperate link.

I agree the site is a great resource and I find my own experiences not always matching TNW's probably since I don't own or use a ceramic cooker. This is where the reader ratings are somewhat helpful as they come from folks using all sorts of cooker designs. When I post a reader review of my experience, I include the cooker design(s) I used the lump with and my corresponding results.
_________________
Let's hope SoEzzy can ditch his heavy hand on photos in 2016!